MDK March Mayhem: The Champion!

By Kay Gardiner and Ann Shayne
April 2, 2018

Leave a Comment

  • It looks like the Hadley with a different yoke design.

  • I had a really hard time with this year’s Mayhem, only because it was agonizing for me to make my picks. The farther it went, the harder it got to pick, since all the patterns were so great! Congrats to Isabell – Humulus has been in my library since it first came out.

  • A beautiful winner!! I have added this to my list of favorites and plan to knit it one day. Isabell’s sweaters have been pinned to my knitting boards for years but I did not realize they were her designs until I just viewed her Ravelry page. All 64 items are to die for – like many others, I just could not make up my mind which one was the winner so thank you to all who voted for making the decision for us!

  • So much fun, thank you all!

  • Congratulations to all the winners. I am knitting Anne Hansen’s Edison next.

  • I started making Humulus a few weeks ago! It’s a wonderful sweater and pattern is beautifully written! You won’t be disappointed!

  • Congratulations, Isabell! Got this on my list, too! Can’t wait to get the yummy yarn and cast on!

  • I always learn something from you two. One day it’s how to butter toast, the next it’s German geography. Love it!

  • Love this, and most of the contenders. It was fun to follow. I have several of the patters; I must need yarn and needles

  • I second the Smonakey! It was really, really hard to choose. Great to have 64 new patterns to play with now.

  • Congrats to the winner! I think I’m going to cast on The Weekender next. 🙂

  • I am delighted Humulus won. I loved this sweater from the beginning, and I had fun with March Mayhem. Thank you.

  • Congrats to a beautiful winner! I’m itching to cast on Fern and Feather now.

  • I loved following along and voting in March Mayhem. Just wondering, how many people voted in each round? I’m trying to convince my basketball-loving co-workers that March Mayhem is a big thing!

  • CONGRATULATIONS!! I’ve loved this sweater since the moment I saw it. So glad that I was able to vote. Can’t wait to cast it on!

  • I am on my third Weekender but love Humulus too!

  • I love Isabel Kramer designs so much! Her designs made me brave enough to cast on my first sweater ever, after years of knitting only scarves and hats. The way she blends simplicity, great design allowing so many different yarns, and beginner-pattern-reading, she is pretty much a perfect designer, in my book. 🙂

  • Runner up? Third place? Miss Congeniality? Can we have the final line up of the last four? Thank you so much for all of the research and production that took to pull together. I like your criteria for the initial selections.

  • If anyone’s interested, there’s a new show on Netflix with Nicola Walker as a gay Anglican priest. It’s called Collateral and it’s a four episode show just released this year.

  • I must admit Humulus was a fave of mine before March Mayhem. It’s now easy to say if I had ofedicted it would have been this one or maybe Big Sister…..

    Thanks again for the all the fun of playing this pattern bombing game! Much more intereting than that hoops thing.

  • Congratulations, Isabell! a worthy winner 🙂

  • To counterbalance all the pleasant comments about Isabell Kraemer’s design, I find Isabell Kraemer’s designs a bit on the boring side – though the photos on the Instagram feed hint at a broader repertoire than her top-down, minimal patterning, no shaping, which gives you far too much stocking stitch [to wit the front cover of Pom Pom Quarterly latest edition is Isabel’s, she has a very identifiable aestetic, like many designers so you don’t need to be told it’s Isabell’s], would imply. She had quite a nice pattern in last month’s Knitter magazine but even then it’s a bit bland somehow. It’s textured but I much prefer the slightly more rustic textured patterns of Thea Colman, Carol Feller, Linda Marveng, Sarah Hatton, Ysolda etc. Isabell’s patterns are maybe great for beginners to colourwork (but to be honest I’d come into that category too). I did notice that the more complex patterns got bounced earlier in the process of March Mayhem. The pattern I personally preferred out of all the patterns was Ysolda’s Threipmuir, despite it being a top-down design. It won’t be a surprise to learn I didn’t vote for Humulus. I voted for her fellow German, Melanie Berg (aka Mairlynd). Her design was far from being one of her best or one of the best in the competition as far as shawls go too. It works to a large degree due to the colours and not the design itself.

  • I am one of those people who loves what appears to me to be the body-skimming ease of most of Isabell’s sweaters. Waist-shaping does not work for me because it implies a curvaciousness that my body cannot live up to, thereby eliciting a lot of confusion (at best) from both on lookers and me. And oversized is way too much fabric. However body-skimming works well – it implies, rather than actually signals a waistline which is flattering on me and the resulting amount of fabric neither overwhelms nor constricts me. (I am short-waisted and have an indented midriff on my thin days but no actual flaring out to the hips which are pretty straight, in case you want a handle on how my body type is shaped:-). Anyways, I love and favorite designs like Isabell’s but may never knit another sweater since it takes me so long to finish one! If I did the slightly dropped neckline of Xstatic is the one I would choose. But the simplicity of any of hers allows you to choose your own yarn and embellishments thereby, for my purposes, preventing boredom.

  • Too funny – my father’s family is from Mundelsheim…less than 10 miles from Besigheim…the kids from Mundelsheim take the bus to Besigheim once they are 5th grade and up to finish their schooling…very cute little city if you ever get a chance to go!

  • i have knitted two of Isabell Kraemer’s patterns and admire tons of others. . . but her famously wide necklines, and low back necklines, don’t make much sense: They may be fast to knit in worsted or even heavier yarns, but those necklines are CHILLY! They’re never shown with the shirt or scarf or shawl that would be a Winter essential for keeping warm, even in the mild winters of Ms Kraemer’s South German state which I’ve traded for Canada’s rougher version.

    For those of us who love the comfort of a sweater on bare skin, a bit more Winter warmth can be knitted into Isabell’s creations with extra cast-on neckline stitches, a bit of fiddling with patterns, and (German!) shortrows to bring the back neck up.